Myth vs Fact
Supplement Myths vs Facts
The supplement industry runs on half-remembered scares and gym-floor folklore. Here are the biggest claims, each given an honest verdict against the actual evidence — the same green, amber and red we score products with, turned on the myths themselves.
Of the 14 claims below, 9 are outright myths, 3 are half-truths, and 2 are confirmed true. Tap any claim for the reality.
Why so many supplement myths stick
Most supplement myths come from one of three places: a single small study blown out of proportion (creatine and hair loss), advice for a specific medical group wrongly applied to everyone (protein and kidneys), or marketing that needs you to believe a product is essential (test boosters, BCAAs, fat burners). Once a claim is repeated enough on the gym floor it feels true, regardless of what the research actually shows.
The honest short version
A very small number of supplements have real evidence behind them — creatine, caffeine, enough protein — and most of the rest is convenience or noise. Get your training, protein and calories right first, add the two or three proven extras if you want an edge, and ignore anything sold as a shortcut. That is the whole game.
Where this page stops
These verdicts are general and evidence-based for healthy adults, and they are about supplements, not medicine. Genuinely low testosterone, kidney disease, heart conditions, pregnancy and medication interactions are all matters for a qualified clinician — not a tub off a shelf and not this page.
Related
Supplement Watch-Outs
Myths are the claims; watch-outs are the actual underdosed products to skip — and what to buy instead.
Related
Supplement Answers
The straight how-much and when questions — dosing, timing and what is actually worth taking.
Skip the myths, get the products right
Every product we track is scored 0–100 on how closely it matches the evidence, so you only pay for what actually works — or let the wizard build your whole stack in a minute.
Informational only — not medical advice. Verdicts are general and evidence-based for healthy adults; if you take medication, have a health condition, are pregnant or breastfeeding, speak to a clinician first.